Many people have been eagerly awaiting compensation under the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) motor finance redress scheme. Following the FCA’s latest announcement, there is understandably some confusion about what happens next.
The short answer is that the compensation scheme hasn’t been cancelled, but parts of it have been temporarily suspended while legal challenges are considered by the Upper Tribunal. Although this means you’ll have to wait longer than expected, it doesn’t mean you’ve lost your right to compensation.
In this post, we explore the FCA’s latest announcement in greater detail.
Why has the scheme been suspended?
The FCA introduced the motor finance redress scheme to compensate customers who may have been mis-sold car finance. However, several organisations – Volkswagen Financial Services, Mercedes Benz Financial Services and Credit Agricole Auto Finance, as well as Consumer Voice – have challenged aspects of the scheme through the courts.
Interestingly, those challenges come from different perspectives. In simple terms, the lenders have argued that the scheme goes too far, while Consumer Voice believes it doesn’t go far enough in compensating affected customers.
As a result, the Upper Tribunal has agreed to hear these legal challenges, either in December of this year or February 2027 (depending on whether any of those involved ask for further expert opinion or disclosure of information). While that process takes place, parts of the scheme have been paused.
What’s actually changed?
The biggest practical change is that lenders aren’t currently required to:
- Calculate compensation under the FCA’s scheme
- Make compensation payments
- Communicate with customers about compensation owed under the scheme
This is intended to avoid firms carrying out work that could potentially have to be repeated if the Tribunal requires changes to the scheme.
However, this is only a partial suspension. The FCA has made clear that lenders must comply with rules that aren’t suspended. This includes continuing to prepare for the scheme behind the scenes by identifying relevant complaints and agreements, and gathering data needed to identify commission arrangements and disclosure practices. What’s more, complaints that fall outside the scope of the scheme should – according to the FCA’s latest announcement – be handled in the usual way.
Does this mean compensation won’t happen?
No.
The delay is frustrating for consumers – but the FCA hasn’t abandoned its compensation scheme. In fact, it has made clear that it will defend it as the “quickest, fairest and most efficient” way of compensating millions of consumers affected by the motor finance commission issue.
What happens next depends on the Tribunal’s decision.
If the scheme is upheld, the FCA expects payments to begin in 2027. But if the Tribunal requires changes, the FCA will decide how best to proceed. That could involve amending the scheme or considering alternative ways for compensation to be paid, such as telling lenders to resolve complaints individually under the usual complaints process.
While there is uncertainty, the FCA has reiterated its position that it’s committed to securing fair compensation for consumers as quickly as possible.
Why is the legal process important?
Delays are disappointing. However, it’s crucial that any compensation scheme is legally robust. This is one of the largest consumer redress exercises ever undertaken in the UK, potentially affecting millions of motorists and involving billions of pounds in compensation.
In these circumstances, it’s not unusual for significant legal issues to be tested before implementation. Although this may feel like another setback, resolving these legal questions now should reduce the risk of greater uncertainty later. And, according to the FCA, some lenders are even exploring ways to compensate consumers, despite the wider uncertainty.
Should you still pursue a car finance claim?
In many cases, yes. Individual circumstances vary from case to case. The FCA has made clear that you’ll be considered for compensation if your agreement involved:
- A discretionary commission arrangement which enabled the broker to change the interest rate to gain higher commission
- A commission arrangement of at least 39% of the total cost of credit and 10% of the loan
- Undisclosed contractual ties that gave the lender exclusive rights or a right of first refusal
Ultimately, if you believe you were mis-sold car finance, don’t assume that your case has disappeared or that your rights have evaporated simply because the scheme has been delayed.
If you haven’t already, you can complain directly to your lender. Alternatively, some people find it helpful to obtain legal advice to help establish whether you have a valid claim and if there are alternative routes available.
The current pause relates specifically to the FCA’s industry-wide compensation process. It doesn’t prevent you from complaining or seeking advice about your position.
What should consumers do now?
Patience is (we’re often told!) a virtue. And for now, it’s unfortunately needed.
Until the Tribunal has heard the legal challenges (either in late 2026 or early 2027) and that process concludes, the FCA’s compensation timetable is effectively on hold.
It’s disappointing, but the issue hasn’t disappeared. The key takeaway? Don’t panic. The latest announcement is a delay. It isn’t a decision that compensation will no longer be paid.
As experts in this area of law, we’re monitoring developments closely and we’ll keep you updated as the legal process progresses. If the Tribunal upholds the FCA’s approach, we’d expect the compensation process to move forward. And if changes are required, we’ll advise on the best course of action and any alternative options available.
If you’re feeling unsure about whether to pursue a car finance complaint, don’t hesitate to contact our specialist team for clear, straightforward advice tailored to your circumstances.
Ready to check if you have a claim?
Simply use the link below to give us a few details and we’ll be in touch. There’s no obligation to go ahead – and no fees if your claim isn’t successful.
Check if you have a claim
